You can only keep one, which do you keep?
 

poll to come.

the left one

Bigfoot
no question

+1

I'll go with Wilson....we're going to need someone when Gonzo retires.

Why Bigfoot and why is it "no question"?

Why Bigfoot and why is it "no question"?

If you're making us decide today then it's Bigfoot without question. Of the two he's the only one that's proven he can produce on Sundays.

Wilson = 6'2" = not likely to replace Gonzalez nor Dunn, IMO.

Because he's not in his first year of converting from one side of the ball to the other.

No $15,000 option?

Ah, but he is a converted player. The majority of his playing came only last year so I wouldn't automatically say that he is miles ahead of Grigsby. Grigsby also plays an important role on special teams. I'm not saying I disagree, just saying it doesn't seem such an easy decision to me. Honestly, I'm not sure which I would pick.

I get that, but at least Wilson has always been an offensive player. Boomer is JUST NOW learning the nuances of how to play offense. But like you said, they'll both make the team just for special teams purposes, if nothing else.

But if I were GM with a gun to my head, it would be Bigfoot.

Bigfoot has more speed, agility, and talent as both a pass-catcher and a blocker, especially in running schemes. He needs to work on his pass-protection.

Boomer is still a n00b. And while younger, the age difference isn't enough to create a valid reason.

I take Bigfoot.

Not to nitpick or anything, but Boomer did play FB in high school. But yeah, I understand what you mean.

Anyways, I would pick Wilson.