Alright, let's settle this once and for all...
 

Who is a better overall baseball player, John Buck or Miguel Olivo?

Where's the Yadier Molina option :D

John buck is the worst person on earth

I haven't noticed Olivo mentioned much, has he been injured or what. Or was he suffering a little slump and they gave him some games off.

i don't know, but if he can move his body at all, he should be the starting catcher.

:thumb:

Sadly, John Suck is a little better.

Miguel Olivo's hustle when he made it to second on a passed ball against the Yankees told me all I need to know. He has more power, desire and baseball sense than Buck. I don't care who calls a better game, and judging by our record, I'd say it doesn't much better, we are only a few games better than last year, when we had Jason Freaking Larue marched out there all the time.

It could be his 53 strikeouts to his 7 walks and the fact that J. Buck has a higher OBP. Sadly, I think its a wash.

yeah where is the Yadie option :D

I'll say BIGFOOT

http://bfro.net/

Olivo.

Royals record with John Buck catching:

33-32

Royals record with Miguel Olivo catching:

10-21

Thread over.

It's pretty even, imo.

But how many of those Buck wins also included Olivo's bat in the lineup at DH?