Fantasy baseball keeper
 

We get one keeper each year and I draft #10.

I can't decide between Braun or Justin Upton. I know Braun is the reigning MVP but Upton is 24 and I expect him to have a huge year and the Dbacks to be better than the Brewers this year.

Thoughts?

What are your scoring categories for hitters?

Yea sorry, didn't give much info.

We do week matchups, scoring head-to-head. Hitting categories are
1 Avg
2 runs
3 homers
4 rbis
5 SBs
6 OBP

Actually, I'm not sure why I asked. If there aren't any salaries involved you have to keep Braun.

Yea I just feel it is a closer decision than most people think. I just like Upton and his upside is tremendously high but Braun being the MVP is hard to pass up. I think he loses a lot of protection without Fielder and I don't see Hart being that productive. Lots of speculation in that I suppose, though.

Correct, no salaries. Just straight draft.

I agree that it's close but you really can't pass on Braun. Even if you end up being wrong you still made the right decision.

Braun, no doubt.

Ok I will put my love for Upton to the side and keep Braun. :)

That would be cool to play.