Alex Smith
 

If Peyton Manning goes to SF, would Alex Smith be bad enough to provide the necessary low-level of competition that Pioli and company are looking for?

No, we're looking for a QB.

NO!

/Thread.

No.

I am not asking if WE want him. I am asking if this is the quality of QB pioli is looking for to "compete" with Cassel

Someone like Seattle or Miami will offer him more than we would to be a starter anyways...

Alex+Harbaugh- Yes
Alex alone- Maybe a slight upgrade over Cassel. Maybe

So pretty much no.

The Chiefs replacing Cassel with another guy that is kinda ok but not going to win for you in all likelyhood only sets us back farther. I also agree a team like SEA would offer him more.

Sadly he would be an upgrade over Cassel.

No.

No.

Alex Smith has much more talent than Cassel.

He has the arm to push the ball downfield and provide enough of a threat to open things up underneath for the RBs. In other words, he's a legitimate game-manager.

Cassel just sucks dicks.

So Alex Smith would prove to be way too good for Pioli to bring in.

It's Brady Quinn.

ROFLROFLROFL

Harbaugh is the QB guru, without Harbaugh Alex Smith probably goes back to suckage

Stanzi

Alex Smith > Dog Turd > Matt Cassel