Who is comeback player of the year
 

Going into today...

Adrian Peterson... 265 attempts, 1,600 yards, 10 touchdowns
*He has another long td run today already

Peyton Manning... 104 QB rating, 3,812 yards, 30 touchdown passes

do you really need to ask?

sincerly,

Peyton

AP

Manning will win it, but Peterson should.

All day

I think Peterson should win the MVP, but Manning will.

They'll give AP the Comeback player award as a consolation prize.

This. Plays a much more bruising and physical position.

Seems like a likey scenario.

AP. Mannings having a great year but AP might have a historic season and he's doing it even though their passing offense has gone into the tank.

I'll give comeback player of the year to AP.
Manning gets my MVP. There is NO WAY the RB position is MORE valuable than the QB position. AP won't even get his team into the playoffs... whereas Manning may take a mediocre Broncos team deep into the playoffs if not the superbowl.

They should both win it co winners if thats possible. They are both playing ****ing great. Its a toss up honestly

AP. no doubt. He didn't have some little neck injury, he ****ing blew out his knee.

That's pretty much how I feel. I vote AP though officially.

"AP should" ???? **** that with a big chocolaty Jamaal Charles dick.

That "mediocre" Bronco team won 8 games with Tim TeBow at QB.

Their defense came on in the middle of the season last year, and have only improved, and their receivers have some talent.

Manning is tapping into that talent, and the defense gets a chance to really play to their strength.