Originally Posted by saphojunkie
Well, it's clearly between Poe, Houston, and Smith.
I picked Smith, purely because he is the only one who replaced a guy from last year's team, and it has made a world of difference.
If we had Poe and Houston playing at this level and still had cassel under center, there's no way we are 4-0.
Cassel would have been dramatically better under Reid. Haley was stank ass. Pittsburgh's offense has been dropping like a stone since the day Haley touched it, despite having a franchise and super bowl winning Quarterback.