Originally Posted by Pam Oliver's Forehead
They are debates. They are debates about how much he sucks. We're trying to determine where he falls on the Plummer-Cassel game manager scale.
So far he's about the same as 2005 Jake Plummer, who "led" a top defense to the AFC Championship game and was routinely sucked off by Broncos faithful. However, he has shown no indications he will match the glory of Cassel's 27/7.
I don't think Smith is any better than Jake Plummer.