Here you are, stuck on numbers again instead of specific instances. Your article points out that democrats used pro forma sessions to prevent GWBush from making recess appointments. Bush respected the constitution and didn't make those appointments. When the Senate tried to do that to Obama, he ignored the constitution and made his appointments anyway.
“[Cruz] might not be the most fun to have a drink at the bar with, but America needs a designated driver.” - Mica Mosbacher, wife of the late Robert Mosbacher, Secretary of Commerce