Fun topic!
Quote:
Originally Posted by kccrow
The way I see it...
QB
1. Johnny Manziel - Texas A&M
2. Teddy Bridgewater - Louisville
3. Derek Carr - Fresno State
4. A.J. McCarron - Alabama
5. Blake Bortles - Central Florida
|
First off, I don't know how anybody could favor anybody in this draft over Bridgewater. Manziel is explosive and fun but he is such a risk/reward versus the low-risk, high-reward guy in Bridgewater.
I absolutely hate McCarron. He will be a Brody-Croyle-esque mess in the NFL.
I'd probably have Brett Smith of Wyoming as my 5th QB.
Quote:
RB
1. Charles Sims - West Virginia
2. Bishop Sankey - Washington
3. Lache Seastrunk - Baylor
4. Tre Mason - Auburn
5. Devonta Freeman - Florida State
|
Sims? I like him, but nowhere near 1st RB worthy. Seastrunk and Mason have #1 RB ability, and Sankey can start in a committee. But Sims will probably never start in the NFL.
I do like Freeman a ton, though.
Quote:
TE
1. Eric Ebron - North Carolina
2. Jace Amaro - Texas Tech
3. Austin Seferian-Jenkins - Washington
4. C.J. Fiedorowicz - Iowa
5. Troy Niklas - Notre Dame
|
Looks great.
Quote:
WR
1. Sammy Watkins - Clemson
2. Mike Evans - Texas A&M
3. Brandon Cooks - Oregon State
4. Marqise Lee - USC
5. Odell Beckham - LSU
|
Lee is not on my Top 5 radar. I'd probably have Matthews as my #5.
Quote:
OT
1. Jake Matthews - Texas A&M
2. Greg Robinson - Auburn
3. Taylor Lewan - Michigan
4. Cyrus Kouandjio - Alabama
5. Jack Mewhort - Ohio State
|
Flip Matthews and Robinson, and Mewhort and Kouandjio, and we're right on.
Quote:
OG
1. Xavier Su'a Filo - UCLA
2. David Yankey - Stanford
3. Gabe Jackson - Mississippi State
4. Travis Swanson - Arkansas (move from center)
5. Cyril Richardson - Baylor
|
Despite the fact that I hate Richardson (Dakota Dozier is my #4), this is fine.
I think Yankey should be so much better than Su'a-Filo, but his measurables spook me.
Quote:
OC
1. Marcus Martin - USC
2. Bryan Stork - Florida State
3. Weston Richburg - Colorado State
4. Tyler Larsen - Utah State
5. Zac Kerin - Toledo
|
This center class is so hilariously awful that I can't knock this list too much; you're having to choose between bad and worse.
Martin's really the only center worth a damn here, though Richburg does have upside. I absolutely hate Stork, who I think is one of the most overrated players in this draft.