Alex Smith did not play great in all 3 playoff games he has played in.
In the Colts game he was outstanding in the first half, and better than some have painted in the second half.
As a 9er against the Saints, he was mediocre through much of the game, but put on his big boy pants to outduel Drew Brees in the final minutes.
Against the Giants he was complete ass, and was every bit as responsible for that loss as was the returner who muffed the 2 punts.
That said, Alex Smith can win you a SB if you provide him with protection, outstanding support in the run game, and the proper weapons.
We clearly have the run, and with Maclin and Kelce, along with Charles, we have enough weapons, even if we don't add another.
What this offense needs most is, despite the ridiculous arguments otherwise (I'm looking at you SNR) is better, more consistent protecction.
__________________
|