Quote:
Originally Posted by Hootie 2.0
not everything is about Alex Smith
Andrew Luck >>>>> Alex Smith
now that we're past that ... if the Chiefs had won the Luck lottery and his play on the field with KC is what it is over in Indy I would be grossly disappointed
nothing I have seen with Andrew Luck, thus far, has shown me he's the next great NFL HOF QB
He's solid ... but he's more Philip Rivers / Eli Manning tier than Peyton Manning / Tom Brady tier.
He has not lived up to his billing in any way, shape, or form [thus far].
But yes, he does have all of the talent in the world ... but so do a lot of guys. I just don't make excuses for poor play.
|
If Andrew Luck played with Charles and our defense, he would not play with the gunslinger mentality that he does. Andrew Luck has to do EVERYTHING for his team to have a chance to win. If he doesn't throw 3 touchdowns, the chances of his team winning are VERY slim. So you saying you would be disappointed by Luck if he played this way with us is not realistic. He wouldn't play this way.