Quote:
Originally Posted by jjchieffan
Yeah throw in his San Francisco stats where he had a new coordinator and or coach every other year to bring down his win percentage. He-s 35-17 as a Chief which is about .870 Winning percentage. Sorry. His pre-Chiefs stats are irrelevant to this conversation. Your smack has failed. But feel free to try again.
|
You're bad at math.
Alex Smith is 35-20 as the Chiefs starting QB (11-4 + playoff loss, 8-7, 11-5 + playoff win + playoff loss, 4-2). That's .636. Which equates to 10 wins a year.
High floor. Low ceiling.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nickhead
in fairness, with all the issues kc has had in the passing game with alex as the starter, he would have won that super bowl for the 49ers if he wasn't benched.  |
Unlikely.
1) Baltimore scored 34 points. Alex Smith wins what, 10 percent of the time when his opponent scores more than 24 points? And it's not like QB play was the issue - Kaerpernick played well, and his only turnover did not lead to points.
2) The Falcons also scored 24 points in the NFC championship game. So again, you're starting at Alex Smith's abysmal record when his opponent scores that much. There's also the matter of the 17-0 deficit Kaerpernick and the 49ers offense rallied from.
3) Kaerpernick and the 49ers also won a shootout against the Packers in the divisional round, with Kaep running for 181 yards and throwing for 263 more.
What is likely, based on Alex's career, is that the 49ers would have beat the Vikings in the opening round, and then lost the shootout in the divisional round to Rodgers.