Quote:
Originally Posted by DaneMcCloud
What the ****? The guy had ONE 10+ game winning season as a QB.
What the **** is wrong with you, beyond the obvious?
|
Originally (i.e. a few posts ago in this thread) your definition of a "franchise QB" was:
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by DaneMcCloud: A Franchise QB is a guy that leads a team to successive winning seasons and wins in the playoffs.
|
Then when presented with Neil O'Donnell (i.e. a game manager/Bubble Screen Alex Smith-type QB who started for Pittsburgh Steelers teams in the 1990's that had 4 consecutive winning seasons and who won in the playoffs... fitting your lame initial definition of a "franchise QB"), you suddenly changed your definition of a franchise QB to be...
Quote:
|
Originally Posted by DaneMcCloud: What the ****? The guy had ONE 10+ game winning season as a QB.
|
So now your definition of a "franchise QB" is not someone who has "successive winning seasons and wins in the playoffs", but has "10+ game winning seasons".
Unfortunately your attempt to improve your criteria for what defines a franchise QB fails because Neil O'Donnell would still qualify as a franchise QB using your pathetic definition.
Neil O'Donnell was Pittsburgh's starting QB when they finished 11-15 in 1992, 12-4 in 1994, and 11-5 in 1995.
So once again... a simple yes or no question that even a dumbshit like yourself can answer... is Neil O'Donnell a franchise QB?