[Mr. Plow]

Originally Posted by Bearcat

I thought he was dreaming, but the end was confusing. He said he saved Charlie twice... he saved him, then he drowned... then on this trip back he saved him from drowning. So this is the third time on the island for him.

And the question has already been asked here, if the key triggers him going back, he wouldn't know what happens after that, so it has to be something else... will they ever say?

A while back Desmond left on his boat, then came back drunk saying he was "back on the damn island"... if leaving the island made him go back in time, he would have had to leave a second time (if this was his third time back). When he left on his boat, he seemed so eager to get off, with no sense of deja vu.... so none of it really makes much sense.

Talk about not making much sense....