Quote:
Originally Posted by DaneMcCloud
I think John lied when he chose the knife. Just like when he denied himself the chance to be a scientist, he denied his instincts and chose an object that signified who he wanted to be, not his true identity. Though in high school, he was obviously a "Knight".
I don't think Keemy is "mad" with island fever. I think he's a killer, plain and simple. Now that the island knows what's going to happen, its instructed John to make sure it's not destroyed.
Apparently, John's been to the island before, possibly in a different life as a member of the Black Rock. It's also possible that through my theory of time travel/different plane of existence, John is also Jacob.
|
I was pretty sure about that too.
I do like the theory of John being Jacob. It makes a lot of sense.