Originally Posted by teedubya
The actor who played Jack Shepard, didn't think your theory was correct during the Jimmy Kimmell interview.
I didn't watch it but I think the writers left the ending open to interpretation for a reason. And that reason is that that everyone would be talking about it for years on end.
If they wrapped it up all in a nice little package with a bow on top, it would have been in direct contradiction to the past 122 or whatever episodes.