Quote:
Originally Posted by Reaper16
My problem with Dane's interpretation is that there doesn't seem to be much "textual" evidence for it beyond Jack "landing" and "dying" in what appears to be the same spot on the island. Dane's interpretation makes logical sense when abstracted from the show but I don't see the in-show support for it.
|
Agreed. Dane I don't know how many times you've seen each episode, but I've watched each episode 3 to 8 times, and not once during any viewing, ever did I think that it was some kind of dream. There was never any evidence for it, ever. If you could provide any other evidence showing it was a dream, I might not argue with you, but nothing else supports the dream theory.
Not once ever did someone change to another person or change clothes before our eyes. Never did anybody stray away from what they were doing on a completely unrelated tangent. All the minute detail we got in the show just doesn't happen in dreams.
P.S. The comment that got me upset was the one about you (Dane) saying that you've talked to many people in the show business and not one of them has a different theory than you. You make it out to seem like we are lesser people when it comes to our opinion about Lost. Show me one person you talked to that was as into the show as me that you talked to. I bet you can't.