I'd take him.
Alex Smith's failure still doesn't make sense to me. He has a very nice arm, he's mobile, he's a hard worker and the kid is actually very smart.
His coaching has to have been complete dogshit because I swear that kid has the talent to be at least an average NFL quarterback. I think that's why the 9ers keep giving him a chance; the talent is there.
If he comes for a 5th rounder or something, sure - I'd take him.
It's my own fault for expecting the Titanic to beat the iceberg this year.