Originally Posted by The Meat Lover's Pizza Face
well that was obviously shot down when they when Quinn and Bautista went and visited the college professor and questioned her
No, not at all. As I mentioned last week, the theory isn't that Gellar never existed, he clearly did. The question is whether he actually exists right now or has become simply a figment of Travis' imagination that helps him along with his murders (like Harry is for Dexter).
And really, I saw more evidence in favor of that theory again this week. Gellar has not been noticed or acknowledged by any character outside of Travis in five episodes despite being in public locations numerous times (and even now with his picture in the paper as a murder suspect he is still oddly willing to go out and risk everything).