Originally Posted by htismaqe
Really? I've used it for both Ich and FW Velvet and it works great. Just as good as copper without the side effects.
The fact is that it still can't kill ich. Ich Attack can essentially nurse your fish through an infection, but anything that 'kills' ich is going to wipe out a reef.
So all you're doing is taking something like my selcon/garlic soak (plus the elements added by water changes), dilluting it in water, adding some phosphate to it and then dumping it directly into your tank as opposed to having them ingest it.
It just seems like surgery with a shotgun to me.