I still think Jay should be leading off against RH pitching.
Furcal isn't a leadoff hitter anymore. Jay's capable of giving you a .350 OBP and nice doubles power. He's not a perfect leadoff hitter since he's not really a base-stealing threat, but he gets on base well and can put himself in scoring position more often than most leadoff men w/ the doubles pop.
The team will be better off with him at 1 than Furcal, IMO.
"Tact is the ability to tell someone to go to hell in such a way that they look forward to the trip"