Quote:
Originally Posted by Chiefnj2
Really?
Petyon - I take Eli. Younger, not coming off a major series of medical issues and Eli is a much better clutch player.
Roethlisberger - Kind of a tossup depending on what system you want to run. I might go with Eli because (a) less wear and tear, (b) history of throwing more TDs, (c) more disciplined.
Stafford - Tough one. Might be the only player between 4 and 10 that I'd take over Eli, only because we don't know his ceiling yet. But, his injury history is pretty troubling and he's still relatively unproven.
Romo - No way.
Rivers - Not close to Eli. Mentally weak.
Ryan - Still ascending, but is not the same player on the road that he is at home.
|
I think your a bit biased against Rivers. If he were a Chief you'd warm up to him. Also, you seemed to struggle with Roethlisberg and Stafford. Not that easy when you really look at it. What about Vick?
I think Vick has matured enough and shown enough to be in the top 5.