Quote:
Originally Posted by milkman
Of course not.
But if talent was all it took to win championships, then Jeff George would be considered by everyone as one of the greatest QB ever, while Johnny Unitas would be sitting on his couch at home talking about his semi-pro football glory days.
|
Alright, let's look at Steve Young vs. Stan Humphries.
'94 Super Bowl 49-26
Young was a failure in TB and ended up in SF as a backup to Montana and replaced him after the infamous Marshall hit.
He took over what was practically a Pro Bowl team. (They cheated the salary cap)
Humphries was brought in from Washington to replace Billy Joe Tolliver on an average team.
Humphries made "clutch" plays all season and the Chargers surprisingly made the Super Bowl.
If you were to switch QBs between the 2 teams do you think the 49ers would have won?
Yeah they'd win 28-26 with Humphries pulling a horseshoe out of his ass.
So, who's better in that situation? Humphries because he was "clutch" or Young even though he would have "choked"