Quote:
Originally Posted by OnTheWarpath58
They get like 11 padded practices. If you think you can accurately evaluate a player when he's competing against his own teammates, you're foolish.
It's a completely different game on Gameday.
Which is why fans get so disappointed when some scrub looks great in camp and then looks like ass in games.
|
You're not listening. How many third and long situations are in a game where Tamba can pin his ears back? Well to get a good evaluation of how well he does that skill, you can simulate a certain situation in a single practice, and repeat it to the extent that you might see over the course of half or even an entire season.
it makes no difference if its a teammate or not, actually I would say that you can evaluate a player BETTER this way. Because if you're evaluating Tamba vs Houston, you can line them both up over Albert and afterwards ask Albert what he thought. You can get more information evaluating VS team than not.
Anothe thing is the endzone camera for game film is never perfect. in practice you get any angle you want and your own tape for review