Originally Posted by Nightfyre
We aren't in a position where we could turn him down.
If you could go into 2013 with a rotation of:
A) the team can contend
B) the team can deal Guthrie at the ASB when Duffy/Paulino is ready to go.
We're not winning with that rotation. We need to get at least one more big pitcher to add with Greinke, along with keeping Guthrie.