Originally Posted by htismaqe
Completely irrelevant question.
No it isn't. You guys are discounting Dex's yards because they didn't all happen as a true WR. Who cares how he gets them. For receiving yards the two are basically equal. But oh no! Dexter didn't start the game listed as a WR! That is such a stupid argument.
As a WR Tate has been better because that is all he does. As a football player whose, get this, job it is to get yards and move the chains Dexter has been better.
I love the scrambling that it is somehow implied he ment "as a WR" when he said Tate was better because that is the only way to save face.
The funniest thing about all of this is that McCluster, in his first year as a "true" WR has more catches and more yards than Tate, even with that phony TD yesterday. All Tate has on Dex is the one actual TD.