Game 1: Fouts put up some good stats, and he played for the team that drafted him. Those add up to a win.
Game 2: Pretty easy win for Manning here. I like Bradshaw, but don't think he was the best QB of his era, let alone all time. Manning can make a case.
Game 3: Aikman gets an easy matchup. Gannon shouldn't be in this discussion.
Game 4: Dawson gets an easy matchup. Blanda doesn't belong in this discussion.
Game 5: A cruel twist of fate puts the Green Bay legends against each other. Bart Starr won't ever lose a game for you, and Brett Fah-vuh-ruh will. However, when you come down to it, the Lombardi Packers were a running team, and Favre could hand off as well as Starr. I have to pick Favre despite my admiration for the Lombardi teams.
Game 6: Another cruel twist of fate. At their peaks, I actually think that Young may have been the better and more unbeatable quarterback. However, I'm never ever betting against Joe Montana, so I'll pick Montana.
Game 7: Easy matchup for Warner here. Esiason shouldn't be in this discussion.
Game 8: Oh, wow. This one is brutal. The best passer of all time versus Mr. Clutch. Who do you pick in a one-game matchup? It's impossible to pick a loser here. With the "at their peak" qualifications, I'll go with Marino, but by the faintest of margins.
Eliminate the racist "Chiefs" nickname and become the Kansas City Ermines. It's time, people.