Thanks guys, this is exactly why I asked. Rep coming everybody's way.
I'll probably not do the Goose Island and Allegash...I tend to like both those breweries, but I can get the stuff they're offering elsewhere here.
Was definitely going to try the Tank 7 an Lips of Faith (pretty much the only New Belgium I can't get here).
I may give the La Parcela a shot, glad you mentioned it even though I said I'm over pumpkins (Brooklyn's Post Road is about the only one I'll still drink now and then). I'm big on sours and lambics so I was going to give the Timmermans Pumpkin Lambicus a go anyway.