Originally Posted by tk13
Don't give me that crap. Anybody who has enough brain activity to not be considered a vegetable could have figured those guys out. I meant the typical figures like Sanchez, Clausen, Tyler Thigpen.
I suppose you'll have to define "going nuts"
Right now you're committing the logical fallacy of claiming all bad drafted 1st round QBs were QBs that CP went nuts over. In reality, CP goes nuts over ANY QB within reach in the draft. About the only counter-example I can think of is Tim Tebow in recent years.
Some QBs get more discussion than others due to hardcore backers (Mecca and Sanchez) and virulent haters (all the "true fans" and Sanchez).
So no, you can't just place all the bad QBs on CP and then leave out the good ones. Luck and RGIII have to be considered.