Originally Posted by The Bad Guy
I just don't see that comparison at all.
I don't, either.
Alex Smith came from Urban Meyer's spread offense. Smith had like five different OC's his first five years and had issues with his mechanics.
Barkley's been in the West Coast offense for four years and has been very successful. Whether or not that translates to NFL greatness is yet to be seen but he's has a very good chance to be a successful NFL QB.