Originally Posted by mcaj22
when Geno Smith gets us from 2 wins to 4 wins in his rookie season, you wont be saying that
I'm not sure what you're getting at, other than that's exactly what Matt Stafford did, essentially. Took an 0-16 team and made them a 2-14 team in his rookie year. Which would kind of support my argument if Geno got us two more wins than this year.
Remember, I said, "Geno Smith is no more risky a QB prospect than Matt Stafford was." I'm not in the business of comparing or saying one's better than the other. I'm talking strictly about both guys coming out of college, which is the only thing we can judge at this point.