View Single Post
Old 12-06-2012, 04:19 AM   #30
Cheater5 Cheater5 is offline
Starter
 
Cheater5's Avatar
 

Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: Fort Bragg, NC
Casino cash: $30983
Quote:
Originally Posted by scott free View Post
Man, sorry to hear that, i've only been in simulated battles, i defer to your expertise.

Tell me the ways i'm wrong, and i swear i dont mean that in some Donger-like, baiting, rhetorical way... i just want to know the truth, i think thats why so many of the vets i know and talk to open up, i get enough military slang and humor to atleast let them know i'm not some fake.

Hit me with some thoughts...
I suppose it's like a law enforcement officer watching a cop movie or TV show that is supposed to be 'gritty and realistic', and hoping that finally someone got close to authenticity. And then realizing very quickly it's nothing more but a polished version of the same soup warmed over.

Apologize for the hijack;
1) NO ONE in Iraq goes ANYWHERE alone. Nope. Never. You don't split your team up to walk alone down alleyways; you don't leave the FOB on your own (at night or any other time). This isn't the streets of the U.S. or any other western nation, or even Kuwait. You intentionally separate yourself in Iraq and you run the very real risk of starring in a grainy video with dudes in hoods standing behind you...
2) EOD techs experience extreme danger every single day (understatement), which leads them to be meticulous, professional, and they calculate risk with a surgeon-like focus. Plus they are rare; this isn't a high density skillset. So, to portray the lead character as a swaggering on-the-edge wildman who risks not only his life recklessly but those of his men...well. He'd be gone. Pack... Your... Sh*t.
3) Dove-tailing with the above; EOD does not go anywhere unescorted. They do not just go meandering around on patrols by themselves. They receive a call, and are ushered (escorted) in and out of an IED site. Unless of course they are already embedded with a unit on a mission.
4) The scene rescuing the Blackwater dudes and making nearly impossible shots by an untrained sniper with a .50 cal (again out on their own just driving around...) is just another data point that erodes realism.

There are some good scenes in that movie. Not many, but there are some. Overall, just too much to overcome and I wrote it off as tripe.
Posts: 731
Cheater5 would the whole thing.Cheater5 would the whole thing.Cheater5 would the whole thing.Cheater5 would the whole thing.Cheater5 would the whole thing.Cheater5 would the whole thing.Cheater5 would the whole thing.Cheater5 would the whole thing.Cheater5 would the whole thing.Cheater5 would the whole thing.Cheater5 would the whole thing.
  Reply With Quote