Originally Posted by Prison Bitch
Not giving Gore a rushing TD is about the dumbest logic imaginable. He scored a TD after running the ball in. That's a rushing TD. This isn't hard. Anyone trying to wrangle out under "letter of the law" is a complete and total loser who I wouldn't play fantasy football with any longer. After I punched them out.
If Hali picks up a fumble and runs it in, he's credited with a def player TD no? So how is this different?
In the second part of your post (where you're correct), you dispute the first part. It wasn't a rushing TD, it was a fumble recovered for a TD. If a league is set up to reward offensive fumble recoveries you get it, if it isn't you don't....should be fairly simple to see.
FWIW, I do have Gore in one league that doesn't reward fumble recoveries and lost......there's no reason to bitch about it though. Scoring settings were set before the season began.