Originally Posted by Rain Man
Brees is in his 30s now, and it'd be hard to give up a #1 pick for a guy in his 30s. That's why Brady and Manning aren't on the list at all.
I want to see more out of Andrew Luck. He got a lot of at-bats this year to produce good production stats, but he wasn't dominating like RGIII was. I'd be tempted to put him in my top ten list due to potential.
How many years can you trust RGIII to take the field? Can he make it through a season & playoffs without being hurt? I'd rather have Luck or Russell Wilson than RGIII. I'd take Geno Smith over RGIII for that I think Geno can succeed & stay healthy for long term.