Originally Posted by milkman
Are you new here?
I am the first to call Peyton a playoff choker, going back years.
Took a ton of shit for that.
I am taking Eli, and not even thinking about looking back.
But my buddy and I were arguing over text about this. I called Manning a definite choker after tonight's performance. He says it isn't fair to call Eli more clutch because those Giants defenses won them games/Superbowls while Peyton played in Indy with shitty defenses.
He claims if they both were Quarterbacking the same team, you would take Peyton because his talent is superior.