Originally Posted by lewdog
Yea I totally agree.
I don't really remember how bad Indy defenses were all those years besides the shit defensive matchup in '03?
It's not like we're saying Indy was blown out every year in the playoffs. They were in a lot of tightly contested games where Peyton just did not make enough plays at the end where it mattered most. In many cases, he threw picks at the wrong time.
I know people talk about the David Tyree unbelievable catch against New England. I am still in awe at the pass Eli threw to Mario Manningham. It's passes like these that I just don't see enough of from Peyton in late game playoff situations.