Originally Posted by O.city
Not to call you out here totally, but lets stop comparing these guys to the best QB's in the game.
Manning and Brady are likely 2 of the best 5 QB's to EVER play. EVER. Lets not start with that.
Barkley isn't deadly accurate. He is accurate, but he doesn't have elite accuracy. He could develop it, sure. But like it has been discussed, Barkley is pretty much topped out mechanically. Changing a little here or there isn't going to make much difference.
He just lacks the arm strength to drive the ball down the field.
I'm not comparing anyone to either, i'm just using them as the accuracy is a product of the system discussion. IMO barkley's ceiling could be that of peyton mannings, at his lowest ceiling he could be a schaub. Who will win you some games but all around is a HORRIBLE QB. But i think the others are right with a matt ryan type QB comparison. Which i would be GREAT with matt ryan