Originally Posted by Sweet Dick Willie
Reid got maximum mileage from mc nabb and vick. Smith is beyond both in potential skills and leadership. We need to just stop with any other scenario because this Deal is......wait for it.........Done.
Posted via Mobile Device
Really based on what is he beyond McNabb?
McNabb was a great QB for a lot of years with the Eagles. He was their leader and someone who maximized his skill set while playing the position.
Look, I like Geno, but the rhetoric about how he has skills that transcend QBs that were truly really good to great in this league has to stop here.
We just need to stop making baseless comparisons to try to strengthen the argument that he should go #1. I'm not disputing he should, but what I am disputing is that you know how good of a leader Geno Smith is. You don't. I don't. No one does. I also think leadership is one of the biggest fluff things ever in sports.
Mike Vick also had the best skill set potential out of any QB drafted in the 2000s. A QB with an incredible arm, and 4.3 speed.
Geno Smith is not beyond that potential skill set. Not even close.