Originally Posted by DaneMcCloud
Over-drafting a QB in the first round doesn't make him worthy of being a first round QB.
However, it doesn't seem to matter. Was Weeden worthy of being a first round QB? Tannehill? McNown? Druckenmiller? Mirer? Sanchez? Russell? Smith? Losman? Grossman? Quinn? VY? Leftwich? Leinart? Dilfer?
In terms of win percentage, their teams all improved coinciding with their drafting.
Meanwhile, here are some guys whose teams got worse once they were drafted: Ryan Clady, Bryant McKinnie, Shawn Andrews, Leonard Davis.