Originally Posted by RunKC
That's up to our brass to decide.
He has everything physically that you could want. He was a winner. He seems smart and appears to have good leadership skills (that's not for sure though).
Problem with him is consistency and mechanics.
Raw but unlimited potential if he puts it together in the right situation. Sounds a lot like McNabb to me.
I just don't like his mechanics to be honest. He's really mechanical looking when throwing and guys like that seem to always have accuracy problems, which he does tend to.
So, no, he doesn't have everything you could want at this point. There is something there and I wouldn't mind to draft him. But he's a guy I'd draft knowing full well he probably isn't playing a meaningful down in the NFL for 2 years.
I think you are forgetting how good McNabb actually was coming out.