Originally Posted by 'Hamas' Jenkins
Depends on the cut of the shirt, TBH. A billowy shirt would look better untucked because it will make you look longer rather than a rotund mass inside a cotton tent. Slimmer cut is fine either way, although if he wants to play it off casual w/ it tucked in he could wear sneakers.
I ended up getting one of those shirts and I conferred online w/ a good female friend of mine, and she said tucked looks better.
I'm wearing some of these.