Originally Posted by Detoxing
How are they being complete idiots? They have a legit argument.
See, you're just as guilty as they are. You wanna play the role of "wait and see" but refuse to acknowledge their very valid argument.
There is no more reason to label them an idiot than there is to label you an idiot.
If you truly were neutral like you say you are, then you'd understand their argument and not label them as "bitching"
I'm neutral in the sense that I think it's important we give the people we were all so excited about and have done a great job otherwise the benefit of the doubt - that's all. I don't claim that Alex will be the best QB we've ever had - only that claiming that our franchise is doomed forever because of it is silly.
I do think comparing Alex (who has improved pretty much every year) to Cassel (who had a moderately OK year once) is completely unfair, but I've never claimed that Alex will be the team's savior.
Maybe that's what it comes down to - I get tired of everyone arguing whether things are black or white when I'd like to see more discussion about what shade of grey it is.