Originally Posted by DaFace
I'm neutral in the sense that I think it's important we give the people we were all so excited about and have done a great job otherwise the benefit of the doubt - that's all. I don't claim that Alex will be the best QB we've ever had - only that claiming that our franchise is doomed forever because of it is silly.
I do think comparing Alex (who has improved pretty much every year) to Cassel (who had a moderately OK year once) is completely unfair, but I've never claimed that Alex will be the team's savior.
Maybe that's what it comes down to - I get tired of everyone arguing whether things are black or white when I'd like to see more discussion about what shade of grey it is.
In 2009 There was a lot of grey, a lot of white, and very little bit of black. Because we're essentially doing the same thing yet again, you're simply seeing a shift and some people around here aren't able to cope with it.
Now we have a lot more who were gray, turning black and a lot more who were white, turning gray.