Quote:
Originally Posted by Hootie
how is Alex Smith a shitty QB?
he is what he is
but people are grossly overreacting about how "bad" he is
some of you people are just miserable human beings
|
Alex is a known commodity, so it is fair to judge him. He has had 6 years of bad and two years of decent.
I think even his defenders admit he is not a franchise QB. Shaub is a franchise QB. Two second rounders for a franchise QB is okay. What you are hearing is a preference to take a chance with an unknown that COULD be a star versus taking a known mediocre placeholder that will prevent us from looking hard for his replacement.