Quote:
Originally Posted by chiefzilla1501
And this is different from Big Ben... how?
The question is, do you want a Peyton Manning that is the model of consistency but then plays average in big games, or do you want a Big Ben/Eli that will have ups and downs in the regular season but then piece together a playoff run that few QBs are capable of? I'll take the latter, please.
|
I've never said Big Ben was elite, because he's not.
I'd take Peyton Manning, without question. The Broncos backed off in the 2nd half in the playoffs last year and wound up losing to a team they were dominating in the first half. They didn't even choose to go for a score before the end of the first half with like 2 timeouts and P. Manning at QB with like 50 seconds on the clock, iirc.