Originally Posted by crazycoffey
You're agreement to a mostly optimistic post confuses me, and you didn't say dumbass.
I believe I am fairly objective about these things.
I hated the trade for Smith and the fact that we didn't draft a QB in this draft.
I firmly believe there are at least 3 QBs from this draft with a much higher ceiling than Alex Smith has reached, and don't believe that Smith is ever going to be anything more than the somewhat mediocre game manager that he has been over the last couple of seasons.
He is far better and clearly far more effective than Matt Cassel.
But far better and far more effective still doesn't equal good.
But the reality is that this team will be better than it has been because Smith is an upgrade.
But I don't give up premium draft picks for a QB that I believe has no shot to ever take this team to a SB.
It's wasted ****ing resources.