Way too many votes for Bo Jackson. The guy was a freakish athlete and a crazy good fielder. He also hit .250, never walked, and struck out 150 times per year. And really how are we talking about a 25 home run guy versus other guys who are hitting 40+?
There's no doubt that Bonds and ARod were the best of the modern generation, but given the juice, I'd go with Griffey and Pujols, even if their career dominance didn't last long (and always had a soft spot for Gwynn, who was impossible to get out). As a pitcher, I'll go with Mariano Rivera (based on guys I saw). It's amazing how one guy can be so successful with just one 92 mph pitch.
|