Quote:
Originally Posted by BigCatDaddy
You're trying to poo poo away the facts. The common phrase was Harbaugh fixed Alex when we look into what he did we find he quit having him throw the ball. As a comparison since some idiots want to compare Trent Green and Alex Smith, Trent actually had his highest QB rating the same year he had his most attempts. Some guys can carry the load and some guys are well, Alex Smith.
I think Alex can be a QB on a winning team the same was he was with the 9ers, the same way Johnson was with the Bucs, the same was Dilfer was with the Ravens, and the same was Grossman was with the Bears.
|
You missed a little part of it. Part of the reason they took the ball out of alex smiths hand in 2011, was because of who he had to throw to.
thats why in the offseason between 2011-2012, they signed Mario, Randy, brought in Celek, drafted aj jenkins, and drafted lemichael james. there was a limit of weapons, especially when Josh Morgan got hurt, Braylon became a distraction, and the wr's were Michael Crabs, swain, hastings, and kyle williams.
But your point is a solid one. I will say this. some guys are alex smith, but, then again some guys are Blaine gabbert, Cassel, fitzpatrick, and give the ball away like its a charity.....