Quote:
Originally Posted by IAmABabySeal
Not a chance in the world...as many faults as he had he was the best QB from that draft. Andy is very good with QB's so whoever you guys get I'd expect good things from him. That's why I've touted Nassib...he's an Andy type kid. Geno would be alright I suppose. Andy likes to throw throw throw though (though with Chilly as an offensive assistant/assistant HC) that might help even things out. What's the word on you guys retaining Bowe? I could have sworn he was supposed to be a FA this year.
|
Okay. Because McNabb was criticized when he was drafted for the exact same things Geno gets nailed for.
"Ehh... McNabb could have won more games. What gives?"
"Doesn't go through his progressions enough."
"He's big and black and athletic. Is he going to get injured a lot?" (the most uninformed losers will use this one)
"Doesn't appear to have "it." He's not a winner. He quits too often. How come it always looks like he's got a bad attitude?"
So you're saying if Geno Smith could have as successful a career with the Chiefs that Donovan McNabb had for the Eagles, we should take that, then?
Because with Andy Reid in town and a QB like Geno, there's absolutely no reason why Geno couldn't be that QB that Andy Reid originally had in Philly.