We had a yard sale a couple of weeks ago. It always amazes me what people buy and don't buy. We had a couple of old scratched up Teflon frying pans that my wife just wanted to throw away. I told her to put 50 cents each on them and we can toss them later if they don't sell. They were almost the first thing we sold.
We had some really nice kitchen items that we priced cheap that didn't go, though they were frequently looked at.
Normally, I would just donate or toss stuff but we had a massive cleaning and ended up with a ton of our boys old toys as well as some pretty nice dishes and kitchen items (a lot of it was never used wedding presents). We also had a couple of bikes, an old table saw, some leftover building supplies and a composter ( the big one that turns), so we figured we would try the yard sale route to get rid of the stuff (I live way out in the sticks and Craigslist doesn't work well here).
We did fairly well but I'm not doing another one. From now on, if we can't donate it, it gets tossed.